There are practical lessons here for directors, liquidators and lawyers and expert legal advice is crucial.
Hinton v Stobinski (Re St Mark Lions Ltd) [2026] EWHC 2386 (Ch) confirms that liquidators cannot usually use section 212 of the Insolvency Act 1986 simply to collect a debt from a director – but they can use it where the director’s conduct amounts to a breach of duty. In this case the company and liquidator recovered £190,153.99 of the £214,195.19 claimed.
There are practical lessons here for directors, liquidators and lawyers and expert legal advice is crucial. For further insight and guidance contact our specialist insolvency team led by Partner, Richard Palmer, Richard.palmer@h-f.co.uk.
Why the case matters
This is the first case in 40 years to consider whether section 212 can cover a debt owed by a director to a company. A straightforward debt claim normally requires an ordinary Part 7 claim. That means paying the full court issue fee and may also involve costs budgeting and disclosure.
However, section 212 may be available if the failure to repay is part of a breach of the director’s duty to the company. The focus of a section 212 claim must be on the misconduct that created the liability, not simply the fact of an unpaid debt.
In this case, the director’s liability arose from his overall conduct of the loan account, which amounted to a breach of duty. It did not arise only because the loan was unpaid. The section 212 application was therefore valid.
Practical lessons for liquidators
Liquidators should decide early whether the director’s conduct regarding a loan can properly be described as a breach of duty. The answer will depend on the facts of each case.
They must also test both the strengths and weaknesses of any explanation suggested by the documents, even if the director does not cooperate.
Practical lessons for directors
A company is legally separate from its directors, including when it is a personal service company. Directors owe separate duties to the company and, in some circumstances, must give priority to creditors’ interests.
Directors must support their case with clear documents. In this case, the director did not provide important evidence, including bank statements for payments he said he had made for the company. The court gave weight only to evidence supported by documents in evidence or by a rational explanation.
A director cannot simply refer financial questions to the company’s accountant; they should understand why the company made, or did not make, a payment.
Practical lessons for lawyers
The court placed particular weight on the fact that the challenged transactions benefited the director. At that stage, creditors’ interests should have carried very significant weight. Where those interests conflicted with action benefiting the director, they should have been given paramount, or almost paramount, weight.
A director must act in good faith in what they believe to be the company’s best interests, subject to duties to creditors.
This is usually a subjective test, but the decision must be rational and there must be evidence that the director actually considered the company’s interests. Neither was present here, so the court applied an objective standard.
Related Insights
Irish Court of Appeal Judgment Leaves Industry with More Questions than Answers
In the case Albert Connaughton v Timber Frame Projects T/A Timber Frame Ireland [2026] IECA 216, the Irish High Court...
Northern Ireland County Court Jurisdiction Doubles to £60,000: What Insurers Need to Know
Significant changes are coming to civil litigation in Northern Ireland. From 30 November 2026, the financial jurisdiction of the County...
Beyond the chatbot: solving insurance’s real AI challenge
Artificial intelligence is becoming commonplace in insurance. It can draft an email, summarise a meeting and save a few minutes...
Reasonable adjustments: could managers and HR professionals face personal liability?
A recent Employment Appeal Tribunal decision has highlighted an important and often overlooked risk for employers, managers and HR professionals...


